9.20.2011

Beyond "It Gets Better"



Has the "It Gets Better" campaign actually contributed to teenage suicides? Because one thing is certain: It sure isn't preventing them.

"It Gets Better" introduced the notion of suicide—that people were doing it as a means of escape—to children who may not have heard of it before. How many kids even knew that killing yourself was a thing before they saw Kim Kardashian talking about it on YouTube? I'm not saying that "It Gets Better" is directly responsible for the suicides that have occurred since its prevalence in social media, but introducing such heavy concepts via popular, tween-friendly, and, to be frank, incredibly stupid celebrities to any unsupervised kid with a computer wasn't very smart. Even though people were saying "don't kill yourself," anyone with half a brain should have realized that seeds can be planted in all sorts of tragic ways when you're attempting to communicate with young, underdeveloped minds.

Even if "It Gets Better" hasn't been responsible for getting kids to consider suicide (and again, I'm not saying it has--directly), it's at least been utterly useless. Instead of encouraging children to cling to an empty, worthless, meaningless catchphrase (which has now become nothing more than a silly meme), is there something else we can do to prevent them from killing themselves? Because despite my cynicism, I really don't want children to kill themselves. I don't want anyone to kill themselves! Is there anything effective that anyone can do?

To start, we should look at why "It Gets Better" didn't work. Quite simply, it was a lie. "It Gets Better" being inherently false should have deterred people from perpetuating it in the first place, but it didn't. I guess people wanted to believe it could be true. People always want to believe in the good. People always want to think that everything is always going to be OK eventually, but of course it never is.

Even the most objective person can not deny that life is truly horrible. And you know what? It gets progressively worse as you get older. Once you pass 30, the only thing weaker than your sense of self-worth is the decrepit bag of flesh and bones you call your body. To be honest, I would much rather go back to the simpler days of being called a faggot in high school than deal with holding down a job, paying bills, and maintaining shitty relationships. Being bullied as a teen was a walk in the park compared to the misery of trying to survive as a functioning adult. Jesus fucking Christ.

So maybe that's how we can help gay children. Tell them that things actually get worse, and that they should cherish the simple horror of being called dumb names while they can. 20 years from now, they'll be lucky if anyone even realizes they exist, much less goes out of their way to bully them. Let's stop lying to gay children and start treating them with some dignity, please. Let's tell them what life is really like once they finish high school, and that their teen years will end up being the best years of their lives. Live in the moment, kids, no matter how horrible it is, and know that the pain of being called "fag" pales in comparison to being fat, sexually deprived, spiteful, bored in a loveless marriage (if you can even legally get gay married, which you probably can't), and trapped in a dead end job (if you're even employed, which you probably aren't).

These kids today don't know how easy they really have it. Let us not lie to them about how great things are going to be, but rather let's tell them to suck it up and realize how great things are right now. These assholes on the playground are nothing compared to the evil bosses, cheating boyfriends, and backstabbing friends waiting in the wings. Yes, being a kid, especially a gay kid, is awful. But being a gay adult is even awfuler. At least as a kid, you haven't developed the demoralizing self-awareness that will ultimately kill you from the inside out.

In short, killing yourself at 14 is a waste. If you have to do it, at least wait until you've truly lost everything as a fully realized, adult failure! At least then it will have really been worth something (i.e., nothing).

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Excellent rebuttal and alternative view. You might enjoy this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cfqO7zmd0oA

Anonymous said...

Fairy tales have been around for centuries because they work.

I prefer some fairy tales over others, same as everybody else.

I happen to believe that things do, in fact, get better over time. They did for me, anyway.

As I got older (I'm 51), my sensitivity to the passage of time diminished as did my urgent, desperate desire for love. That "rounding-off" of the sharp edge of experiencing life must sound like a pretty crappy prospect to a young person and rightly so. But for me it turned out to be better than the alternative.

JenniferJones1010@hotmail.com said...

I honestly just think you are a bitch. Maybe you are the one that should look on the BRIGHTER side of things. You have so much negative to say about life as an adult, maybe YOU should get over that and live in the moment, and be happy with what you have!!

And FYI, most teenagers/adults that do kill themselves isn't because of one reason. (such as bullying) Most of them actually suffer from mental disorders for years (yes, years, even when they are 14!!) before they actually do kill themselves.

I in no way agree with suicide as any answer, but it's not as simple as one day waking up and not wanting to live any longer. It takes months, years to get to that point, and any person searching google about suicide is now going to come across your uneducated blog about how life only gets worse.

You talk about "it gets better" as being the cause of higher suicide rates, but my friend, in reality it is YOU. People like you that say, it's ok, GIVE UP, it's only going to get worse! Shame on you!!

Maybe you should do some research, or even talk to ONE person that had attempted to kill themselves, and you'll realize that everything you blogged about is so untrue!

But it's ok...IT WILL GET BETTER!
Get educated before ranting about things you don't understand. At least the celebrities are TRYING to give kids HOPE...when all you are doing is SHATTERING IT!

"HOT GUY" said...

yes, i agree with you; ur writing is so fascinating; i've read ur entire blog but dont know why: except u have a unique take on things...could u write more or an ebook or short story?

Anonymous said...

JJ1010, it might just be possible that one of the many causes of suicide is the predictable rebuke some people get when they express how they really feel.

gimme brains said...

i have to say, i liked this post. but then you sounded pretty demeaning to kids saying you have it worse, not being young and wild n free anymore. yeah "faggot" isn't worse than the impending life altering complications in the world, but suffering harsh bullying is pretty unbearable when you're forced to go to school and feel like there's no way out. all i gotta say is i'm thankful that's over. only reason i'd wish to go back is to kick some bullies' asses.

sonicfrog said...

I haven;t even read the post yet.... I just want to say I'm glad you're back blogging.

Will put you back on my blog-roll (had to rebuild it after a major server crash)

Mike

sonicfrog said...

OK. There is one major flaw in the post.... You haven't shown that IGB hasn't worked. The suicide of one kid who make a IGB video does not mean that it hasn't stopped others from doing the same. There are probably stats out there that show whether the suicide rates of gay teens have gone up or down. I think it would be interesting to see if the IGB campaign has made any dent at all since its inception.

Even the most objective person can not deny that life is truly horrible. And you know what? It gets progressively worse as you get older. Once you pass 30, the only thing weaker than your sense of self-worth is the decrepit bag of flesh and bones you call your body. To be honest, I would much rather go back to the simpler days of being called a faggot in high school than deal with holding down a job, paying bills, and maintaining shitty relationships.

Ah, we pay the bills of adulthood with the currency of our youth!

Me?... Meh. Wouldn't want to go back. My life as a teen was way way shittier than my life as an adult. At 47, there are aches and pains and other stuff. Yes, I was healthier at 27. I can't jog the 5 miles with the ease that I used to... can barely get down half the block before practically passing out... But, hell, that's life. We're young, waste it on frivolous pursuits, then we get old, and kind of miss those frivolous pursuits. I do what I can to stay healthy, but I definitely have learned how to enjoy life much and the things in it, something that could only come about due to the years I've been walking around on the planet and the accumulation of the experiences along the way.

PS. And yes, that "paid those bills with our youth" is lifted from one of my songs.

PPS. Gods, I HATE the new captia on google!

price per head service said...

I am thoroughly convinced in this said post. I am currently searching for ways in which I could enhance my knowledge in this said topic you have posted here. It does help me a lot knowing that you have shared this information here freely